Close reading and evidence
Students start the year reading harder texts and backing up what they say with specific lines from the page. They learn to tell the difference between what a text states directly and what it suggests.
This is the year reading and writing turn into argument. Students stop just summarizing a book or article and start picking it apart, weighing the evidence an author uses and judging whether the case holds up. In their own essays, they make a clear claim, take on the other side fairly, and back every point with specific quotes from the text. By spring, students can write a multi-paragraph argument that introduces a claim, answers a counterclaim, and cites strong evidence from what they read.
Students start the year reading harder texts and backing up what they say with specific lines from the page. They learn to tell the difference between what a text states directly and what it suggests.
Students look at how writers build meaning through structure, point of view, and word choice. They notice how a single word or image can shift the tone of a passage or shape how a reader feels about a character.
Students write essays that take a clear position and address the other side fairly. They pull evidence from articles and books, check whether sources are trustworthy, and cite their sources in a standard format.
Students compare how the same subject is handled in different formats, such as a novel and a film or an article and a documentary. They judge speakers and writers for sound reasoning and spot weak or misleading evidence.
Students lead and join group discussions on complex topics, building on what others say instead of talking past them. They give prepared presentations with slides or visuals and adjust how they speak based on the audience.
Students write stories, poems, or creative pieces that respond to a text, theme, or personal experience. They work on pacing, dialogue, and vivid detail so a reader can picture the scene and feel the moment.
| Standard | Definition | Code |
|---|---|---|
| Word choice for meaning and style Grades 9-10 | Students learn how word choice, tone, and sentence structure shift depending on context, then use that awareness to write more precisely and read more closely. | NY-9-10L3 |
| Figuring out unfamiliar words Grades 9-10 | Students figure out what unfamiliar or tricky words mean by using context clues, word roots, or a dictionary. The goal is to choose the right strategy for the word in front of them, not rely on just one approach. | NY-9-10L4 |
| Figurative language and word meanings Grades 9-10 | Students study how figurative language works, such as metaphors and irony, and why word choice matters. They look at how related words differ in meaning and tone, like the gap between "stubborn" and "determined." | NY-9-10L5 |
| Academic vocabulary for reading and writing Grades 9-10 | Students learn and use the precise words a subject demands, in essays, discussions, and reading. When an unfamiliar word matters, students figure out what it means and put it to work on their own. | NY-9-10L6 |
| Using a style manual to edit writing Grades 9-10 | Students learn to format and edit their writing according to a recognized style guide, such as MLA or APA. That means correct citations, consistent punctuation, and the layout conventions their teacher or subject requires. | NY-9-10L3a |
| Using context clues to figure out word meaning Grades 9-10 | When students hit an unfamiliar word, they use the surrounding sentences and the word's place in the sentence to figure out what it means, rather than stopping to look it up. | NY-9-10L4a |
| Word forms that shift meaning and part of speech Grades 9-10 | Students learn how changing a word's ending shifts its meaning and job in a sentence. "Analyze" becomes "analysis" becomes "analytical," each playing a different role depending on where it lands. | NY-9-10L4b |
| Using dictionaries and thesauruses to clarify words Grades 9-10 | Students look up unfamiliar words in a dictionary or thesaurus to confirm spelling, pronunciation, meaning, or word origin. They choose the right reference for the job, whether a general dictionary or a subject-specific glossary. | NY-9-10L4c |
| Checking a word's meaning in context or a dictionary Grades 9-10 | Students look up an unfamiliar word in a dictionary or test their best guess against the surrounding sentences to confirm they got the meaning right. | NY-9-10L4d |
| Figures of speech: euphemism and oxymoron Grades 9-10 | Students read lines where a writer uses phrases like "friendly fire" or "living death" and explain what the figure of speech means and why the writer chose it. | NY-9-10L5a |
| Shades of meaning between similar words Grades 9-10 | Words like "thin," "lean," and "gaunt" share a basic meaning but carry different feelings or judgments. Students study those shades of difference and explain why a writer's word choice matters. | NY-9-10L5b |
| Standard | Definition | Code |
|---|---|---|
| Finding proof in the text Grades 9-10 | Students back up every claim about a story or article with direct quotes or details pulled from the text, then push further by asking their own questions about what the text leaves unanswered. | NY-9-10R1 |
| Theme and central idea in a text Grades 9-10 | Students identify the main idea or theme of a story or article, then trace how specific details build and sharpen that idea across the text. They also write a clear, unbiased summary of what they read. | NY-9-10R2 |
| How characters and ideas change through a text Grades 9-10 | Students trace how a person, event, or idea changes across a text and explain what drives those changes. The focus is on connection: how one moment shapes the next. | NY-9-10R3 |
| Figurative and connotative word meanings Grades 9-10 | Students figure out what words mean in context, including when a word carries emotional weight or is used figuratively. They look at how word choice shapes the tone and meaning of a passage. | NY-9-10R4 |
| How structure and intent shape meaning Grades 9-10 | Structure shapes meaning. Students look at how a story or poem is built and ask why the author made those choices, then do the same with nonfiction, tracing how individual sentences or sections push a reader toward a particular idea. | NY-9-10R5 |
| Author's point of view and purpose Grades 9-10 | Students figure out why an author made specific choices, who's speaking, what angle they're coming from, and what they want readers to believe, including ideas the author hints at but never states directly. | NY-9-10R6 |
| Comparing how two formats tell the same story Grades 9-10 | Students compare how the same topic or event comes across in two different formats, like a documentary film and a written article, and notice what each one highlights, leaves out, or changes. | NY-9-10R7 |
| Spotting weak arguments in a text Grades 9-10 | Students read a written argument and decide whether it holds up. They check if the reasons given actually support the claim and if there is enough evidence to back it up. | NY-9-10R8 |
| Judging whether a text is good Grades 9-10 | Students pick their own standards for judging a piece of writing, then use those standards to explain why the text works well or falls short. | NY-9-10R9 |
| Standard | Definition | Code |
|---|---|---|
| Group discussion with evidence and preparation Grades 9-10 | Students read or research the material before a group discussion, then use specific evidence from that reading to push the conversation deeper and keep it grounded. | NY-9-10SL1 |
| Judging sources in different formats Grades 9-10 | Students pull together information from sources like videos, charts, and speeches, then judge whether each one is trustworthy, accurate, and actually relevant to the topic at hand. | NY-9-10SL2 |
| Spotting weak arguments and false evidence Grades 9-10 | Students listen to a speech or presentation and judge whether the speaker's argument holds up. They spot weak logic, one-sided evidence, or claims that stretch the truth. | NY-9-10SL3 |
| Presenting ideas clearly to an audience Grades 9-10 | Students organize a spoken presentation so the main point is clear, the evidence backs it up, and the whole thing fits the audience they're talking to. | NY-9-10SL4 |
| Using visuals to strengthen a presentation Grades 9-10 | Students choose photos, charts, or video clips to make a presentation clearer and more compelling. The visuals support the argument, not just decorate the slides. | NY-9-10SL5 |
| Adjusting speech for formal and informal settings Grades 9-10 | Students adjust how they speak depending on the situation, using formal English for a class presentation or job interview and a more casual tone in a small group discussion. | NY-9-10SL6 |
| Setting norms for group discussions Grades 9-10 | Students practice running a group discussion like a small team: agreeing on ground rules, setting a goal for the conversation, and dividing up responsibilities before the work begins. | NY-9-10SL1b |
| Connecting ideas and bringing others into discussion Grades 9-10 | Students ask questions that connect the conversation to bigger ideas, pull quieter classmates into the discussion, and push back on or verify conclusions others have made. | NY-9-10SL1c |
| Weighing other views and updating your own Grades 9-10 | In a class discussion, students listen to different viewpoints, sum up where people agree and where they don't, and explain their own thinking when it needs backing up. They update their views if someone makes a strong point. | NY-9-10SL1d |
| Standard | Definition | Code |
|---|---|---|
| Argument writing with evidence Grades 9-10 | Students write a formal argument about a real topic or text, backing their claim with solid reasoning and specific evidence from reliable sources. | NY-9-10W1 |
| Informational writing that explains complex ideas clearly Grades 9-10 | Students write essays or reports that explain a complex topic clearly. That means choosing the right information, organizing it in a logical order, and analyzing what it means rather than just listing facts. | NY-9-10W2 |
| Writing stories with structure and detail Grades 9-10 | Students write stories, real or imagined, that follow a clear sequence of events. The details and structure work together to pull the reader through from beginning to end. | NY-9-10W3 |
| Creative writing inspired by reading Grades 9-10 | Students write a creative response to something they've read or experienced, using the techniques that fit the form, whether that's a poem, a short story, or a script. | NY-9-10W4 |
| Finding evidence in texts to support writing Grades 9-10 | Students pull quotes and details from what they read to back up their ideas in writing. The goal is to show that the argument or analysis comes from the text itself, not just the writer's opinion. | NY-9-10W5 |
| Research that starts with your own questions Grades 9-10 | Students pick a question worth investigating, then search for answers using sources. If the question is too broad or too narrow, they adjust it so the research actually goes somewhere useful. | NY-9-10W6 |
| Research with sources, citation, and plagiarism Grades 9-10 | Students find and compare sources on a research topic, judge which ones actually help answer their question, and weave the useful details into their writing without copying. They cite every source in a standard format. | NY-9-10W7 |
| Arguing a point and addressing the other side Grades 9-10 | Students write an argument by stating a clear position, acknowledging the strongest opposing view, and organizing their reasons and evidence so the logic holds together. | NY-9-10W1a |
| Backing up claims and counterclaims with evidence Grades 9-10 | Students build an argument by backing up their main position with evidence, then fairly addressing the other side. They weigh the strengths and weaknesses of both views, keeping in mind what their reader already knows and cares about. | NY-9-10W1b |
| Precise words for complex topics Grades 9-10 | Writing about complex topics, students choose words that fit the subject, picking technical or subject-specific terms when they make the meaning clearer and more exact. | NY-9-10W1c |
| Transitions that connect complex ideas Grades 9-10 | Students choose transition words and phrases that show exactly how ideas connect, whether one idea builds on another, contrasts with it, or qualifies it. The writing holds together because the connections between sentences and paragraphs are made explicit. | NY-9-10W1d |
| Conclusions that explain why the argument matters Grades 9-10 | Students write a closing paragraph that tells readers why the argument matters, not just that it has ended. The conclusion gives the whole piece a reason to exist. | NY-9-10W1e |
| Style and tone for the writing task Grades 9-10 | Writing style and tone should fit the task. A lab report calls for different word choices than a personal essay, and students learn to shift their voice to match what they're writing. | NY-9-10W1f |
| Organize complex ideas with clear connections Grades 9-10 | Students open an informational or explanatory piece by setting up the big idea clearly, then arrange the details so readers can see how the pieces connect and what makes each one different. | NY-9-10W2a |
| Supporting details that fit the audience Grades 9-10 | Students back up their main idea with specific facts, quotes, and details pulled from sources. The evidence should fit what the audience already knows about the topic, not just any detail that seems related. | NY-9-10W2b |
| Precise words for complex topics Grades 9-10 | Writing about complex topics means choosing the right words for the subject. Students use specific vocabulary and exact phrasing so readers understand the full weight of the idea, not just a simplified version of it. | NY-9-10W2c |
| Transitions that connect complex ideas Grades 9-10 | Students practice linking ideas across paragraphs with transition words and phrases that show how one point connects to, contrasts with, or follows from the next. The goal is a reader who never loses the thread. | NY-9-10W2d |
| Conclusions that explain why the topic matters Grades 9-10 | The final paragraph wraps up an informative piece by explaining why the topic matters, not just restating what was already said. | NY-9-10W2e |
| Style that fits the writing task Grades 9-10 | Writing style means choosing words and a tone that fit the assignment. A lab report and a personal essay need different voices, and students learn to switch between them on purpose. | NY-9-10W2f |
| Hook readers with a strong opening Grades 9-10 | A narrative's opening needs to pull the reader in. Students write an introduction that sets up a conflict or situation, establishes who is telling the story, and makes clear whose eyes we're seeing it through. | NY-9-10W3a |
| Narrative techniques: dialogue, pacing, and description Grades 9-10 | Students practice the craft moves that make a story feel real: dialogue that sounds like actual people talking, pacing that controls how fast the action moves, and description that puts a scene in the reader's head. | NY-9-10W3b |
| Sequencing events smoothly in a narrative Grades 9-10 | Students arrange scenes and details in an order that feels natural to read. They use time cues, transitions, and shifts in pacing to keep the story moving without jarring jumps. | NY-9-10W3c |
| Vivid word choice in narrative writing Grades 9-10 | Students choose specific words and sensory details (sounds, textures, smells) to make a story's scene or character feel real to the reader, not just described. | NY-9-10W3d |
| Narrative conclusions that wrap up the story Grades 9-10 | Students write an ending that grows naturally out of the story they told. The conclusion looks back at what happened and leaves the reader with a sense that something shifted or settled. | NY-9-10W3e |
The annual test New York gives to students who have been identified as English Language Learners. It checks speaking, listening, reading, and writing in English and decides whether a student is ready to exit ENL services.
The placement test New York gives to students within ten school days of enrolling, when a parent survey suggests the student may need English language services. Results decide whether the student is identified as an English Language Learner.
Students read longer, harder texts and write longer, more careful responses. They build arguments backed by quotes from the reading, write stories with real craft, and join class discussions where they have to actually defend what they think. Most assignments ask for evidence, not just opinion.
Ask students to read aloud a tricky page and then say it back in their own words. If a word stops them, have them guess from the sentence first, then check a dictionary. Five quiet minutes of this beats an hour of frustrated silent reading.
At this level, an opinion only counts if it is tied to specific lines from the text. Ask students to point at the sentence in the book that proves their claim, then write that sentence into the essay and explain it. That move alone usually raises the grade.
A common order is narrative first to rebuild voice and detail, then informative writing to practice organizing complex ideas, then argument writing with counterclaims, and research woven through the second half. Save the longest argument piece for spring, once students can already handle evidence and citation.
Three keep coming back: picking strong textual evidence instead of the first quote they find, working with counterclaims fairly, and using a citation style consistently. Short weekly drills land better than long mini-units.
Memorizing lists in isolation does not stick. Students do better when they meet new words in real reading, notice patterns like analyze and analysis, and use the words in their own writing the same week. Asking what a word means in this sentence is the most useful question at home.
Set norms early, assign roles like questioner, evidence-finder, and summarizer, and require everyone to come with one quote and one question already written down. When students have something on paper, they speak. Rotating roles weekly spreads the talking around.
By spring, students should write a clear multi-paragraph argument with a real counterclaim, pull strong quotes from a text without being told where to look, and discuss a reading by referring to specific lines. If those three hold up across different texts, they are ready.
Pick one paragraph from whatever students are reading and ask two questions: what is the writer trying to say, and which sentence shows it. Then ask them to write one sentence that answers both. Short, steady practice builds the habit that essays and tests reward.